Care Carta

Methodology

How each day's results are reached, and how to dispute one.

Each day

Finding the file. Care Carta starts from a catalog of hospitals. For each one it reads the hospital's cms-hpt.txt, the short file at the root of its website that 45 CFR Part 180 requires, naming its machine-readable price file. It finds the hospital's own entry in that file: the only price file listed, an exact match on the hospital's name, or a price file that declares the hospital's Type 2 NPI. A hospital without a cms-hpt.txt is audited from the price-file address in the catalog. If Care Carta can't tell which file is the hospital's, the hospital isn't audited that day, and the list of hospitals says why.

Downloading it. The rule requires the file to be accessible to automated searches and downloads, so Care Carta requests it the way an automated client does: no login, no payment, no form. It records what each request returned. Each source is checked daily; a file the server reports unchanged may not be downloaded again.

Checking it. The file goes through CMS's own validator, then Care Carta's checks: whether the file belongs to this hospital, whether it can be downloaded as the rule requires, whether the charges and details it lists are encoded as the rule requires, and whether it was updated within the past year. Care Carta cannot tell from the file whether every service, payer or modifier the hospital has is listed; the checks that would need that are marked "not assessed". That makes 33 checks, grouped on each hospital's page by the section of the rule they come from. Each check says what it found.

Publishing. The day's results are published each morning, one page per hospital. The analysis of a file's contents is reused from an earlier day only while both the file and the checks are unchanged.

How a result is reached

Every check ends in one of six results, explained on what the results mean. A check that needs evidence from outside the file, or that Care Carta hasn't built yet, is "not assessed". A check Care Carta tried but couldn't decide, for example because the file couldn't be read, is "couldn't determine". Neither is a pass.

Some download failures say little on their own: a refused request, a web page served in place of the file, a server error, or a connection failure. These count against a hospital only when the same address failed the same way on an earlier day, and, for a refusal, when every route Care Carta has to the file was refused. Until then the result is "couldn't determine". A missing file (an HTTP 404 or 410) fails at once.

A hospital with several price files gets results for each one. Summaries across hospitals use each check's most serious result across a hospital's files.

A result is what Care Carta's automated checks observed on that day. It is not a legal determination; see Legal and what Care Carta doesn't check.

Disputing a result

If you think a result is wrong, whether you work for the hospital or not, write to disputes@carecarta.com. Please include the hospital (a link to its page here is best), the check, the date, and what the hospital's file or website shows.

Care Carta reviews the result against what it recorded that day. If the check got it wrong, Care Carta fixes the check and corrects the published results it affected, and a corrected result says so. If the result stands, Care Carta replies with why. A hospital that changes its file is checked again the next day, without having to write.