{"schemaVersion":2,"hospital":{"key":"330078","name":"SISTERS OF CHARITY HOSPITAL","displayName":"Sisters of Charity Hospital","displayCity":"Buffalo","location":"BUFFALO, NY","identifiers":{"ccn":"330078","npi_type_2":"1790727543"}},"date":"2026-09-28","planKey":"national:2026-09-28:cdc5e7a710039c158be06a0521bcf44d9455bccf","publishedAt":"2026-09-29T05:48:53.466Z","summary":{"total":33,"passed":21,"failed":0,"blocked":0,"notApplicable":0,"couldNotDetermine":11,"notAssessed":1,"checked":21,"passRate":1},"files":[{"runKey":"national-work:2026-09-28:cdc5e7a710039c158be06a0521bcf44d9455bccf:mrf-9d3c5b86407b63628a25:attempt-2","evaluatedAt":"2026-09-28T10:24:26.097Z","sharedWithOthers":0,"sourceLinks":{"homepage":"https://www.chsbuffalo.org/sisters-of-charity-hospital/","cms_hpt_txt":"https://www.chsbuffalo.org/cms-hpt.txt","current_mrf":"https://www.chsbuffalo.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/16-0743187_Sisters-of-Charity-Hospital_StandardCharges.csv","transparency_page":"https://www.chsbuffalo.org/billing-insurance/price-transparency/"},"artifact":{"sha256":"a2d0f7cbdf93f29c7634766b1a10bdd583917ca20ad0e75245f40aa5fcfdd500","size_bytes":8358626532,"display_size":"8358.6 MB","display_format":"CSV","last_observed_change_at":"2026-09-28T10:24:26.097Z"},"ruleset":{"key":"hpt-v3","version":"catalog v2","dataDictionaryVersion":"3.0.0"},"summary":{"total":33,"passed":21,"failed":0,"blocked":0,"notApplicable":0,"couldNotDetermine":11,"notAssessed":1,"checked":21,"passRate":1},"groups":[{"key":"attestation","rules":[{"title":"MRF correctly encodes the accuracy and completeness attestation","detail":"The completed structural evaluation reported no deficiency for this nonconditional check.","result":"PASS","ruleKey":"hpt.mrf.cms.attestation","authority":["45 CFR 180.50(a)(3)(iii)"],"statusLabel":"Passed","display":"PASS"},{"title":"MRF correctly encodes the attester's name","detail":"The completed structural evaluation reported no deficiency for this nonconditional check.","result":"PASS","ruleKey":"hpt.mrf.cms.attester_name","authority":["45 CFR 180.50(a)(3)(iv)"],"statusLabel":"Passed","display":"PASS"}],"title":"Attestation and responsible official","groups":[],"result":"PASS","authority":"45 CFR 180.50(a)(3)","statusLabel":"Passed","distribution":{"FAIL":0,"PASS":2,"BLOCKED":0,"INDETERMINATE":0,"NOT_APPLICABLE":0},"display":"PASS","displayCounts":{"PASS":2}},{"key":"hospital_mrf_information","rules":[{"title":"MRF declares this hospital's Type 2 NPI","detail":"The MRF declares this hospital's Type 2 NPI 1790727543 among 3 NPIs.","result":"PASS","ruleKey":"hpt.mrf.identity.npi","authority":["45 CFR 180.50(b)(2)(i)(A)"],"statusLabel":"Passed","display":"PASS"},{"title":"MRF correctly encodes its template version and update date","detail":"The completed structural evaluation reported no deficiency for this nonconditional check.","result":"PASS","ruleKey":"hpt.mrf.cms.version_and_date","authority":["45 CFR 180.50(b)(2)(i)(B)"],"statusLabel":"Passed","display":"PASS"}],"title":"Hospital and MRF information","groups":[],"result":"PASS","authority":"45 CFR 180.50(b)(2)(i)","statusLabel":"Passed","distribution":{"FAIL":0,"PASS":2,"BLOCKED":0,"INDETERMINATE":0,"NOT_APPLICABLE":0},"display":"PASS","displayCounts":{"PASS":2}},{"key":"standard_charges","rules":[{"title":"MRF lists a gross charge for every item and service","detail":"This check could not be made because an earlier check could not be determined: \"CareCarta parsed the whole MRF\".","result":"INDETERMINATE","ruleKey":"hpt.mrf.gross_charges_complete","authority":["45 CFR 180.50(b)(2)(ii)"],"statusLabel":"Couldn't determine","display":"COULD_NOT_DETERMINE","reason":"CareCarta could not read the hospital's file, and the CMS validator did not find it invalid."},{"title":"MRF lists a discounted cash price for every item and service that has one","detail":"This check could not be made because an earlier check could not be determined: \"CareCarta parsed the whole MRF\".","result":"INDETERMINATE","ruleKey":"hpt.mrf.cash_prices_complete","authority":["45 CFR 180.50(b)(2)(ii)"],"statusLabel":"Couldn't determine","display":"COULD_NOT_DETERMINE","reason":"CareCarta could not read the hospital's file, and the CMS validator did not find it invalid."},{"title":"MRF correctly encodes the de-identified minimum negotiated charge","detail":"No structural deficiency was reported, but the applicable record population has not been classified; no pass or not-applicable inference was made.","result":"INDETERMINATE","ruleKey":"hpt.mrf.cms.minimum_charge","authority":["45 CFR 180.50(b)(2)(ii)"],"statusLabel":"Couldn't determine","display":"COULD_NOT_DETERMINE","reason":"CareCarta could not tell whether this requirement applies to this file."},{"title":"MRF correctly encodes the de-identified maximum negotiated charge","detail":"No structural deficiency was reported, but the applicable record population has not been classified; no pass or not-applicable inference was made.","result":"INDETERMINATE","ruleKey":"hpt.mrf.cms.maximum_charge","authority":["45 CFR 180.50(b)(2)(ii)"],"statusLabel":"Couldn't determine","display":"COULD_NOT_DETERMINE","reason":"CareCarta could not tell whether this requirement applies to this file."}],"title":"Standard charges","groups":[{"key":"payer_specific","rules":[{"title":"MRF correctly encodes payer and plan names","detail":"The completed structural evaluation reported no deficiency for this nonconditional check.","result":"PASS","ruleKey":"hpt.mrf.cms.payer_and_plan","authority":["45 CFR 180.50(b)(2)(ii)(A)"],"statusLabel":"Passed","display":"PASS"},{"title":"MRF correctly encodes how each charge was established","detail":"The completed structural evaluation reported no deficiency for this nonconditional check.","result":"PASS","ruleKey":"hpt.mrf.cms.methodology","authority":["45 CFR 180.50(b)(2)(ii)(B)"],"statusLabel":"Passed","display":"PASS"}],"title":"Payer-specific negotiated charge","groups":[{"key":"rate_expression","rules":[{"title":"MRF expresses each negotiated rate as a dollar amount, percentage, or algorithm","detail":"The completed structural evaluation reported no deficiency for this nonconditional check.","result":"PASS","ruleKey":"hpt.mrf.cms.rate_form","authority":["45 CFR 180.50(b)(2)(ii)(C)"],"statusLabel":"Passed","display":"PASS"},{"title":"Percentage and algorithm rates give enough information to derive a dollar amount","detail":"This check could not be made because an earlier check could not be determined: \"CareCarta parsed the whole MRF\".","result":"INDETERMINATE","ruleKey":"hpt.mrf.algorithm_derivable","authority":["45 CFR 180.50(a)(3)(iii)","45 CFR 180.50(b)(2)(ii)(C)"],"statusLabel":"Couldn't determine","display":"COULD_NOT_DETERMINE","reason":"CareCarta could not read the hospital's file, and the CMS validator did not find it invalid."}],"title":"Rate expression and methodology","groups":[{"key":"allowed_amounts","rules":[{"title":"MRF correctly encodes the 10th percentile allowed amount","detail":"This check could not be made because an earlier check could not be determined: \"The MRF has percentage or algorithm rates\".","result":"INDETERMINATE","ruleKey":"hpt.mrf.cms.allowed_p10","authority":["45 CFR 180.50(b)(2)(ii)(C)(2)"],"statusLabel":"Couldn't determine","display":"COULD_NOT_DETERMINE","reason":"CareCarta could not read the hospital's file, and the CMS validator did not find it invalid."},{"title":"MRF correctly encodes the median allowed amount","detail":"This check could not be made because an earlier check could not be determined: \"The MRF has percentage or algorithm rates\".","result":"INDETERMINATE","ruleKey":"hpt.mrf.cms.allowed_median","authority":["45 CFR 180.50(b)(2)(ii)(C)(2)"],"statusLabel":"Couldn't determine","display":"COULD_NOT_DETERMINE","reason":"CareCarta could not read the hospital's file, and the CMS validator did not find it invalid."},{"title":"MRF correctly encodes the 90th percentile allowed amount","detail":"This check could not be made because an earlier check could not be determined: \"The MRF has percentage or algorithm rates\".","result":"INDETERMINATE","ruleKey":"hpt.mrf.cms.allowed_p90","authority":["45 CFR 180.50(b)(2)(ii)(C)(2)"],"statusLabel":"Couldn't determine","display":"COULD_NOT_DETERMINE","reason":"CareCarta could not read the hospital's file, and the CMS validator did not find it invalid."},{"title":"MRF correctly encodes the count of allowed amounts","detail":"This check could not be made because an earlier check could not be determined: \"The MRF has percentage or algorithm rates\".","result":"INDETERMINATE","ruleKey":"hpt.mrf.cms.allowed_count","authority":["45 CFR 180.50(b)(2)(ii)(C)(2)"],"statusLabel":"Couldn't determine","display":"COULD_NOT_DETERMINE","reason":"CareCarta could not read the hospital's file, and the CMS validator did not find it invalid."}],"title":"Allowed-amount statistics","groups":[],"result":"INDETERMINATE","authority":"45 CFR 180.50(b)(2)(ii)(C)(2)","statusLabel":"4 couldn't be determined","distribution":{"FAIL":0,"PASS":0,"BLOCKED":0,"INDETERMINATE":4,"NOT_APPLICABLE":0},"display":"COULD_NOT_DETERMINE","displayCounts":{"COULD_NOT_DETERMINE":4}}],"result":"INDETERMINATE","authority":"45 CFR 180.50(b)(2)(ii)(C)","statusLabel":"5 couldn't be determined","distribution":{"FAIL":0,"PASS":1,"BLOCKED":0,"INDETERMINATE":5,"NOT_APPLICABLE":0},"display":"COULD_NOT_DETERMINE","displayCounts":{"PASS":1,"COULD_NOT_DETERMINE":5}}],"result":"INDETERMINATE","authority":"45 CFR 180.50(b)(2)(ii)(A)-(C)","statusLabel":"5 couldn't be determined","distribution":{"FAIL":0,"PASS":3,"BLOCKED":0,"INDETERMINATE":5,"NOT_APPLICABLE":0},"display":"COULD_NOT_DETERMINE","displayCounts":{"PASS":3,"COULD_NOT_DETERMINE":5}}],"result":"INDETERMINATE","authority":"45 CFR 180.50(b)(2)(ii)","statusLabel":"9 couldn't be determined","distribution":{"FAIL":0,"PASS":3,"BLOCKED":0,"INDETERMINATE":9,"NOT_APPLICABLE":0},"display":"COULD_NOT_DETERMINE","displayCounts":{"COULD_NOT_DETERMINE":9,"PASS":3}},{"key":"item_service","rules":[{"title":"MRF correctly encodes each item or service description","detail":"The completed structural evaluation reported no deficiency for this nonconditional check.","result":"PASS","ruleKey":"hpt.mrf.cms.description","authority":["45 CFR 180.50(b)(2)(iii)(A)"],"statusLabel":"Passed","display":"PASS"},{"title":"MRF correctly encodes the inpatient or outpatient setting","detail":"The completed structural evaluation reported no deficiency for this nonconditional check.","result":"PASS","ruleKey":"hpt.mrf.cms.setting","authority":["45 CFR 180.50(b)(2)(iii)(B)"],"statusLabel":"Passed","display":"PASS"},{"title":"MRF correctly encodes drug units and measurement type","detail":"No structural deficiency was reported, but the applicable record population has not been classified; no pass or not-applicable inference was made.","result":"INDETERMINATE","ruleKey":"hpt.mrf.cms.drug_units","authority":["45 CFR 180.50(b)(2)(iii)(C)"],"statusLabel":"Couldn't determine","display":"COULD_NOT_DETERMINE","reason":"CareCarta could not tell whether this requirement applies to this file."}],"title":"Item and service information","groups":[],"result":"INDETERMINATE","authority":"45 CFR 180.50(b)(2)(iii)","statusLabel":"1 couldn't be determined","distribution":{"FAIL":0,"PASS":2,"BLOCKED":0,"INDETERMINATE":1,"NOT_APPLICABLE":0},"display":"COULD_NOT_DETERMINE","displayCounts":{"PASS":2,"COULD_NOT_DETERMINE":1}},{"key":"billing_coding","rules":[{"title":"MRF correctly encodes billing codes and code types","detail":"The completed structural evaluation reported no deficiency for this nonconditional check.","result":"PASS","ruleKey":"hpt.mrf.cms.billing_code","authority":["45 CFR 180.50(b)(2)(iv)(A)-(B)"],"statusLabel":"Passed","display":"PASS"},{"title":"MRF lists every applicable modifier and its charges","detail":"This check could not be made because an earlier check could not be determined: \"CareCarta parsed the whole MRF\".","result":"INDETERMINATE","ruleKey":"hpt.mrf.modifiers_complete","authority":["45 CFR 180.50(b)(2)(iv)(C)"],"statusLabel":"Couldn't determine","display":"COULD_NOT_DETERMINE","reason":"CareCarta could not read the hospital's file, and the CMS validator did not find it invalid."}],"title":"Billing and coding information","groups":[],"result":"INDETERMINATE","authority":"45 CFR 180.50(b)(2)(iv)","statusLabel":"1 couldn't be determined","distribution":{"FAIL":0,"PASS":1,"BLOCKED":0,"INDETERMINATE":1,"NOT_APPLICABLE":0},"display":"COULD_NOT_DETERMINE","displayCounts":{"PASS":1,"COULD_NOT_DETERMINE":1}},{"key":"cms_format","rules":[{"title":"MRF passes the CMS validator without errors","detail":"The completed structural evaluation reported no deficiency for this nonconditional check.","result":"PASS","ruleKey":"hpt.mrf.cms.template","authority":["45 CFR 180.50(c)(2)"],"statusLabel":"Passed","display":"PASS"}],"title":"CMS file format","groups":[],"result":"PASS","authority":"45 CFR 180.50(c)(2)","statusLabel":"Passed","distribution":{"FAIL":0,"PASS":1,"BLOCKED":0,"INDETERMINATE":0,"NOT_APPLICABLE":0},"display":"PASS","displayCounts":{"PASS":1}},{"key":"publication_access","rules":[{"title":"MRF downloads without payment","detail":"CareCarta retrieved the file without payment.","result":"PASS","ruleKey":"hpt.mrf.access.no_payment","authority":["45 CFR 180.50(d)(3)(i)"],"statusLabel":"Passed","display":"PASS"},{"title":"MRF downloads without an account or password","detail":"CareCarta retrieved the file without an account or password.","result":"PASS","ruleKey":"hpt.mrf.access.no_login","authority":["45 CFR 180.50(d)(3)(ii)"],"statusLabel":"Passed","display":"PASS"},{"title":"MRF downloads without submitting personal information","detail":"CareCarta retrieved the file without submitting personally identifiable information.","result":"PASS","ruleKey":"hpt.mrf.access.no_personal_info","authority":["45 CFR 180.50(d)(3)(iii)"],"statusLabel":"Passed","display":"PASS"},{"title":"MRF downloads to an automated client","detail":"An automated HTTP client downloaded the declared MRF successfully.","result":"PASS","ruleKey":"hpt.mrf.access.automated","authority":["45 CFR 180.50(d)(3)(iv)"],"statusLabel":"Passed","display":"PASS"},{"title":"MRF is a CSV or JSON file, optionally compressed","detail":"The downloaded artifact provides CSV that can be processed as structured text.","result":"PASS","ruleKey":"hpt.mrf.format.csv_or_json","authority":["45 CFR 180.50(d)(4)"],"statusLabel":"Passed","display":"PASS"},{"title":"MRF file name follows the CMS convention","detail":"The published file name 16-0743187_Sisters-of-Charity-Hospital_StandardCharges.csv matches the required identifier, hospital-name, and standardcharges structure.","result":"PASS","ruleKey":"hpt.mrf.format.filename","authority":["45 CFR 180.50(d)(5)"],"statusLabel":"Passed","display":"PASS"},{"title":"cms-hpt.txt is published and uses the required fields","detail":"The cms-hpt.txt file uses the required canonical fields and valid values.","result":"PASS","ruleKey":"hpt.txt.conforms","authority":["45 CFR 180.50(d)(6)(i)"],"statusLabel":"Passed","display":"PASS"},{"title":"cms-hpt.txt links this hospital's MRF","detail":"The cms-hpt.txt entry \"Sisters of Charity Hospital\" links this hospital's MRF (https://www.chsbuffalo.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/16-0743187_Sisters-of-Charity-Hospital_StandardCharges.csv).","result":"PASS","ruleKey":"hpt.txt.links_mrf","authority":["45 CFR 180.50(d)(6)(i)"],"statusLabel":"Passed","display":"PASS"},{"title":"Homepage has a link labelled Price Transparency","detail":"A labeled Price Transparency link (https://www.chsbuffalo.org/billing-insurance/price-transparency/) was observed in the acquired hospital homepage HTML.","result":"PASS","ruleKey":"hpt.website.price_transparency_link","authority":["45 CFR 180.50(d)(6)(ii)"],"statusLabel":"Passed","display":"PASS"}],"title":"Publication and accessibility","groups":[],"result":"PASS","authority":"45 CFR 180.50(d)(1)-(6)","statusLabel":"Passed","distribution":{"FAIL":0,"PASS":9,"BLOCKED":0,"INDETERMINATE":0,"NOT_APPLICABLE":0},"display":"PASS","displayCounts":{"PASS":9}},{"key":"update_frequency","rules":[{"title":"MRF was updated within the past 12 months","detail":"The MRF reports 04/01/2026, within one year of this audit observation.","result":"PASS","ruleKey":"hpt.mrf.updated_within_year","authority":["45 CFR 180.50(e)"],"statusLabel":"Passed","display":"PASS"}],"title":"Update frequency","groups":[],"result":"PASS","authority":"45 CFR 180.50(e)","statusLabel":"Passed","distribution":{"FAIL":0,"PASS":1,"BLOCKED":0,"INDETERMINATE":0,"NOT_APPLICABLE":0},"display":"PASS","displayCounts":{"PASS":1}},{"key":"shoppable_services","rules":[{"title":"Website offers a qualifying shoppable-services list or price estimator","detail":"CareCarta has not built an evaluator for the shoppable-services disclosure (45 CFR 180.60) yet, so this check cannot be decided.","result":"INDETERMINATE","ruleKey":"hpt.website.shoppable_services","authority":["45 CFR 180.60(a)(1)","45 CFR 180.60(a)(2)"],"statusLabel":"Not assessed","display":"NOT_ASSESSED","reason":"CareCarta has not built this check yet."}],"title":"Shoppable services disclosure","groups":[],"result":"INDETERMINATE","authority":"45 CFR 180.60","statusLabel":"Not assessed","distribution":{"FAIL":0,"PASS":0,"BLOCKED":0,"INDETERMINATE":1,"NOT_APPLICABLE":0},"display":"NOT_ASSESSED","displayCounts":{"NOT_ASSESSED":1}}]}],"history":[{"id":"2026-09-27","evaluatedAt":"2026-09-27T19:48:08.903Z","summary":{"total":33,"passed":21,"failed":0,"blocked":0,"notApplicable":0,"couldNotDetermine":11,"notAssessed":1,"checked":21,"passRate":1},"groups":[{"key":"attestation","result":"PASS"},{"key":"hospital_mrf_information","result":"PASS"},{"key":"standard_charges","result":"COULD_NOT_DETERMINE"},{"key":"item_service","result":"COULD_NOT_DETERMINE"},{"key":"billing_coding","result":"COULD_NOT_DETERMINE"},{"key":"cms_format","result":"PASS"},{"key":"publication_access","result":"PASS"},{"key":"update_frequency","result":"PASS"},{"key":"shoppable_services","result":"NOT_ASSESSED"}]},{"id":"2026-09-28","evaluatedAt":"2026-09-28T10:24:26.097Z","summary":{"total":33,"passed":21,"failed":0,"blocked":0,"notApplicable":0,"couldNotDetermine":11,"notAssessed":1,"checked":21,"passRate":1},"groups":[{"key":"attestation","result":"PASS"},{"key":"hospital_mrf_information","result":"PASS"},{"key":"standard_charges","result":"COULD_NOT_DETERMINE"},{"key":"item_service","result":"COULD_NOT_DETERMINE"},{"key":"billing_coding","result":"COULD_NOT_DETERMINE"},{"key":"cms_format","result":"PASS"},{"key":"publication_access","result":"PASS"},{"key":"update_frequency","result":"PASS"},{"key":"shoppable_services","result":"NOT_ASSESSED"}]}],"enforcement":{"detail":"CMS enforcement records were not evaluated in this bounded audit.","status":"NOT_EVALUATED"},"hospitalResponse":{"detail":"No hospital response is recorded for this bounded audit.","status":"NONE_RECORDED"}}