The Standardization Problem Nobody’s Talking About #
When patients receive a medical bill, they see a final amount due. What they don’t see is the complex, often inconsistent process that generated that number. As someone who has worked with both healthcare providers and insurance companies, I’ve witnessed firsthand how the lack of standardization in medical coding practices directly impacts healthcare costs and transparency.
The Many Ways to Code a Procedure #
One of the most surprising aspects of medical billing is that identical procedures can be coded in dramatically different ways depending on:
-
Provider Preferences: Different healthcare systems often develop their own “preferred” coding methods based on historical practices.
-
EMR System Variations: The electronic medical record system a practice uses can influence how procedures are coded and submitted.
-
Regional Differences: Coding practices can vary significantly by geographic region, creating inconsistencies even within the same insurance network.
-
Specialty-Specific Approaches: Specialists may code identical procedures differently than primary care physicians.
These variations aren’t just administrative nuances—they directly affect what patients pay and what insurers cover.
Case Study: A Simple Blood Test #
To illustrate this problem, consider a routine comprehensive metabolic panel (CMP), one of the most common blood tests ordered:
- Hospital A submits this as a single bundled code (80053).
- Hospital B itemizes each component of the test with separate codes.
- Independent Lab C uses the bundled code but adds modifiers for collection and handling.
For the patient with a high-deductible plan, these coding differences can result in price variations of 30-300% for the exact same test.
How Inconsistent Coding Affects Patients #
The impact of these inconsistencies extends beyond simple confusion:
-
Unpredictable Out-of-Pocket Costs: Patients cannot reliably predict what they’ll pay for services across different providers.
-
Hindered Price Shopping: Even with price transparency tools, comparing costs becomes almost impossible when the same service is coded differently.
-
Denied Claims: Valid services may be denied coverage when coding variations conflict with insurer expectations.
-
Delayed Care: Uncertainty about costs leads many patients to delay necessary treatment.
The Technology Gap #
While healthcare has advanced tremendously in clinical capabilities, the systems for coding and billing remain fragmented. Most providers and insurers operate with:
- Legacy systems that don’t communicate effectively with each other
- Outdated coding reference materials
- Limited interoperability between platforms
- Manual processes vulnerable to human error
The Path to Standardization #
At Care Carta, we believe that true price transparency requires addressing these foundational coding inconsistencies. Our approach focuses on:
-
Code Mapping Technology: Creating intelligent systems that can recognize and standardize different coding approaches.
-
Provider Education: Working with healthcare systems to adopt consistent coding best practices.
-
Insurance Integration: Developing platforms that communicate directly with insurance systems for real-time eligibility and pricing.
-
Patient-Friendly Translations: Converting complex coding into understandable service descriptions.
The Future of Transparent Healthcare Pricing #
Standardizing medical coding won’t happen overnight, but it’s an essential step toward genuine price transparency. By creating consistent, predictable coding practices, we can build a healthcare system where patients know exactly what they’ll pay before receiving care.
The technology to achieve this exists today. What’s needed is the will to implement it across our fragmented healthcare ecosystem.
Madeleine Barbier specializes in insurance systems and medical coding at Care Carta, with experience spanning both private practices and insurance companies.